Sign In

The Challenges of Being a Project Manager, as Felt on the New York Subway

Haebom
Most metropolitan and special cities in Korea have subways or light rail and similar infrastructure. When we go to take these trains or while waiting, we often check the train information board to see which train is coming and when. But if you go to the subways of cities like New York or some famous Western European cities, you’ll sometimes see that there aren’t any display boards like this at all—in fact, it’s quite common. Why do you think that is?
1.
Complex signal system: The New York City subway’s signaling is extremely old and intricate. This system lacks the technical capacity to pinpoint the exact real-time location of each train or report it accurately. For your reference,the New York subway has been running since 1904,making this its 119th year.
2.
Challenges with upgrades: Modernizing the signaling and upgrading to technology that can accurately track trains is hugely complicated, requiring a great deal of money and time. Back in 1968, New York State came up with a plan for an extensive upgrade to standardize and improve the signal systems on different lines. But that plan was never completed.
3.
Insufficient budget and resources: Massive upgrades like these call for billions of dollars in investment and significant resources, but the NYC subway system has struggled to secure enough funding and manpower. The following shows the best system they could put in place at the time.
4.
Problems with policy and priorities: Decision-makers don’t have clear priorities when it comes to improving the subway, and various projects get duplicated or overlap. Because of this, there is a lack of consistent and coherent improvements.
a.
Too many vested interests: Railway corporations, local governments, construction companies, citizens—the subway is already such a key part of daily life that stopping it for upgrades is nearly impossible.
b.
Recently, with advances in technology, new solutions have started to appear, but there’s still a lot of concern about whether these can really be implemented, given the complicated web of vested interests.
5.
Technical limitations: The New York subway still relies on outdated technology, so there are major technical challenges in bringing it up to date. For example, introducing a new system—like CBTC—to replace the old signaling is highly complex and demands a lot of time and resources.
6.
Aging infrastructure: The infrastructure of New York’s subway—especially the signaling system—is really deteriorated, and modernizing it is a huge and complicated project. Both MTA and ATS, the U.S. subway corporations, are currently making all sorts of efforts to implement CBTC.

Conclusion

The lack of countdown clocks in the NYC subway isn’t just about technology—there’s a mess of financial, policy, and infrastructure difficulties behind it. Obviously, sorting these out will call for a lot of time, funding, and some strong policy decisions.
If we imagined this as software development, how would we go about balancing legacy issues, customer convenience, and maintaining or improving existing features? It might not seem directly related to IT, but from a project management angle, this is a fascinating problem to think about.
Subscribe to 'haebom'
📚 Welcome to Haebom's archives.
---
I post articles related to IT 💻, economy 💰, and humanities 🎭.
If you are curious about my thoughts, perspectives or interests, please subscribe.
haebom@kakao.com
Subscribe