Big results from small differences in data analysis
Haebom
These days, thanks to LLM, I can study data analysis more easily and enjoyably. In the process, I also learned about the problem of reproducibility and found a good article about it, so I'd like to share it with you.
The issue of reproducibility has long been discussed in scientific research. Reproducibility refers to the ability of other researchers to obtain the same results when they repeat the same experiment.
Problems with reproducibility
Misconception of statistical significance: Researchers often rely solely on “statistical significance” to interpret their results. This is simply an oversimplified approach to a complex problem.
Choice of research method: Results can vary greatly depending on the researcher's method of analysis. For example, some researchers may not consider certain variables.
Example
Bronze Bird Growth and Sibling Rivalry
Research Background
One of the many factors that influences the growth of bronze birds is competition between siblings. This study analyzed how sibling competition affects growth and survival in bronze birds.
Analysis method
Statistical analysis: Researchers used a variety of statistical methods to analyze the data.
Selection of variables: The researchers considered a number of variables, including the age of the parent birds, the number of siblings, and the amount of food provided.
Results and Interpretation
Researcher A analyzed that sibling competition has a positive effect on growth.
On the other hand, researcher B interpreted this competition as having a negative impact on growth.
These differences were found to depend on the analysis method and the variables selected.
Germination of Eucalyptus Seeds and Effects on Grass
Research Background
Germination of eucalyptus seeds is affected by several environmental factors.
This study focused on how the presence of grass affects the germination of eucalyptus seeds.
Analysis method
Experimental design: The researchers conducted germination experiments with eucalyptus seeds in environments with and without grass.
Data collection: We collected various indicators such as germination rate, growth rate, and survival rate.
Results and Interpretation
The presence of grass has been shown to reduce the germination rate of eucalyptus seeds.
However, it was confirmed that these results can vary significantly depending on the analysis method and experimental conditions.
Interpretation of results and solutions
Average Analysis: When all analyses are combined, the results are somewhat meaningful. However, results can vary greatly depending on the analysis method.
Uncertainty in scientific research: These diverse results demonstrate the uncertainty inherent in scientific research.
Therefore, you can overcome it in the following way.
Applying multiple analysis methods: Applying multiple analysis methods to one study can increase the reliability of the results.
Statement of analytical dependence: Research papers should state which analytical method was chosen and how it affects the results.
📚 Welcome to Haebom's archives. --- I post articles related to IT 💻, economy 💰, and humanities 🎭. If you are curious about my thoughts, perspectives or interests, please subscribe. Would you like to be notified when new articles are posted? 🔔 Yes, that means subscribe. haebom@kakao.com
