If thousands of people controlled a single Pokémon character through chat commands, would everyone cooperate to finish the game as quickly as possible? In Twitch Plays Pokémon, the introduction of a more efficient, democratic voting system sparked resistance from participants who wanted to preserve the original, chaotic anarchy mode. For them, completing the game wasn't the only thing that mattered. How they played together mattered, too. Cooperation toward a shared goal can conflict with cooperation to preserve a particular way of playing.